Language: one of life’s great inventions

The 9 April 2005 issue of the New Scientist magazine features a special article on “Life's top 10 greatest inventions”.

“Evolution is blind and brutish,” the magazine reports, “but, every now and then, it stumbles across a truly stunning innovation that rewrites the rules of life.”

The top 10 evolutionary achievements highlighted include the eye, the brain, photosynthesis - and language.

“As far as humans are concerned, language has got to be the ultimate evolutionary innovation,” writes Kate Douglas. “It is central to most of what makes us special, from consciousness, empathy and mental time travel to symbolism, spirituality and morality. Language may be a defining factor of our species, but just how important is it in the evolutionary scheme of things?

“A decade ago, John Maynard Smith, then emeritus professor of biology at the University of Sussex, UK, and Eors Szathmary from the Institute of Advanced Study in Budapest, Hungary, published The Major Transitions in Evolution, their description of life's great leaps forward. They identified these crucial steps as innovations in the way information was organised and transmitted from one generation to the next - starting with the origin of life itself and ending with language.

“Exactly how our ancestors took this leap is possibly the hardest problem in science, Szathmary says. He points out that complex language - language with syntax and grammar, which builds up meaning through a hierarchical arrangement of subordinate clauses - evolved just once. Only human brains are able to produce language, and, contrary to popular belief, this ability is not confined to specialised regions in the brain such as Broca's and Wernicke's areas. If these are damaged others can take over. Szathmary likens language to an amoeba, and the human brain to the habitat in which it can thrive. ‘A surprisingly large part of our brain can sustain language,’ he says.

“But that raises the question of why this language amoeba doesn't colonise the brains of other animals, especially primates. Szathmary is convinced the answer lies in neural networks unique to humans that allow us to perform the complex hierarchical processing required for grammatical language. These networks are shaped both by our genes and by experience. The first gene associated with language, FOXP2, was identified in 2001, and others will surely follow.

“So why don't our close evolutionary relatives, chimps and other primates, have similar abilities? The answer, recent analysis seems to suggest, lies in the fact that while humans and chimps have many genes in common, the versions expressed in human brains are more active than those in chimps. What's more, the brains of newborn humans are far less developed than those of newborn chimps, which means that our neural networks are shaped over many years of development immersed in a linguistic environment.

“In a sense, language is the last word in biological evolution. That's because this particular evolutionary innovation allows those who possess it to move beyond the realms of the purely biological. With language, our ancestors were able to create their own environment - we now call it culture - and adapt to it without the need for genetic changes.”

Related links

EITI Limited is not responsible for the content of external Internet sites.

Life's top 10 greatest inventions
Read the full text of this article on the New Scientist web site.